Skip to Main Content

A Truck Making a Wide Right Turn Hit My Car: Who Is at Fault in Florida?


By The Attorneys of Jimenez Mazzitelli Mordes

The Bottom Line

  • Long trucks often swing left before turning right, leaving a gap that a car can drive into. When the truck completes the turn, it can crush the car against the curb. Truckers call this a “squeeze play.”
  • Florida law (section 316.151) says a right turn must be made as close as practicable to the right-hand curb or edge of the road. A truck driver who must swing wide still has to make sure the turn is safe.
  • Fault is often shared. Florida reduces your recovery by your share of fault and bars recovery above 50%, so the evidence about turn signals, mirrors and position matters.
  • No fees or costs unless we win. Free consultation, open 24 hours: (305) 548-8750.

Hialeah’s east side was laid out decades before 53-foot trailers. Tractor-trailers making deliveries to warehouses, auto-parts shops and distribution centers around East 4th Avenue, the blocks near East 25th Street and the streets off Okeechobee Road have to turn on narrow corners with cars parked close by. To clear the corner, the driver often pulls left or into a second lane first. To a driver behind, that can look like the truck is changing lanes or turning left, and the open space on the right looks like room to pass. It is not.

Why are wide right turns so dangerous?

A tractor-trailer’s rear wheels track well inside the path of its front wheels on a turn, and the driver has a large blind spot along the right side of the trailer. A car that pulls into the gap on the right can disappear from the driver’s mirrors and be pinned as the trailer comes around.

Cyclists, scooter riders and pedestrians on the corner face the same danger. The trailer’s rear wheels can mount the curb, and a person standing at the crosswalk can be hit by the side of the trailer rather than the front of the truck.

Who is at fault in a wide-turn truck crash?

It depends on what each driver did. A truck driver who swings wide must signal, check the right-side mirrors and make sure no one is in the gap before turning. A car driver who passes a signaling truck on the right, or squeezes into a space that is clearly closing, may share the blame.

Fact Points toward
Truck turned without a right-turn signal, or signaled late Truck driver at fault
Truck swung into a second lane with no warning and no mirror check Truck driver at fault
Car was already alongside the truck before the truck began its turn Truck driver at fault (the driver should have seen it)
Car passed a truck that was clearly signaling and turning right Shared fault, sometimes mostly the car driver
Trailer mounted the curb and hit a pedestrian or cyclist Usually the truck driver and carrier

Under Florida’s modified comparative fault rule (section 768.81), if you are 50% or less at fault, your recovery is reduced by your percentage. If you are found more than 50% at fault, you recover nothing. Trucking insurers know this, so they often argue that the car “should not have been there.”

What evidence decides these cases?

  • Video. Fleet dash cameras, nearby business cameras and traffic cameras often show the signal and the truck’s path.
  • The truck’s data. Speed and braking from the engine module, and the driver’s logged hours.
  • Damage pattern. Where the trailer hit the car tells a reconstruction engineer where each vehicle was.
  • The corner itself. Lane width, parked cars, curb damage and whether the truck had a legal route to the delivery.
  • The driver’s training. Trucking companies are expected to train drivers on turns and mirrors, and those records can be requested in a lawsuit.

Because the truck’s data and video can be overwritten, a preservation letter should go to the trucking company quickly. Our Hialeah truck accident lawyer page explains the evidence we request and who can be held responsible, and our Miami truck accident lawyers handle these claims across the county.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a truck allowed to use two lanes to make a right turn?

Florida requires right turns to be made as close as practicable to the right-hand curb. On some corners a long truck cannot make the turn without swinging wide, but the driver still has to signal, check the mirrors and make sure the turn can be made safely. Swinging wide is not a license to turn into a car.

I was passing the truck on the right. Can I still recover?

Possibly. Florida allows recovery if you are 50% or less at fault, reduced by your share. If the truck gave no clear signal, or you were already beside it when it began to turn, much of the fault may fall on the truck driver. The video and the damage pattern usually decide it.

Who pays my medical bills after a truck turn crash?

Your own PIP pays first for part of your medical bills and lost wages if you get care within 14 days. Losses beyond PIP, including pain and suffering, are claimed against the truck driver’s employer and its insurance, which is usually much larger than a car’s.

Hit by a turning truck? Call (305) 548-8750 — free consultation, open 24 hours.

No fees or costs unless we win. Hablamos español.