Skip to Main Content
(332) 266-6524New York

Hurt on a New York Construction Site Without Papers: Can You Still Get Compensation?


By The Attorneys of Jimenez Mazzitelli Mordes

The Bottom Line

  • In New York, your immigration status generally does not stop you from bringing a construction injury claim against the property owner, the general contractor or other companies on the site.
  • New York’s highest court held in Balbuena v. IDR Realty (2006) that federal immigration law generally does not bar an undocumented worker from recovering lost wages under the Labor Law. The answer can change if false work documents were used to get the job.
  • New York workers’ compensation generally covers employees regardless of immigration status.
  • A lawyer’s consultation is confidential. No fees or costs unless we win: (332) 266-6524. Hablamos español.

A large share of the people who build New York are immigrants, and many of them work without legal status. When one of them falls from a scaffold or is hit by a falling load, the first fear is often not the injury but the consequences of speaking up: losing the job, being reported, or being told that people “without papers” have no rights. Under New York law, that last part is generally wrong.

Can an undocumented worker sue after a construction accident in New York?

Generally yes. New York’s Labor Law protections, including the Scaffold Law (§ 240) and § 241(6), protect workers on covered sites without asking about immigration status. An injured worker can usually bring a claim against the owner, the general contractor and other responsible companies, just like any other worker.

As with any construction injury, you usually cannot sue your own employer because of the workers’ compensation law. The claim is against the other companies that owned the property, ran the job or supplied the equipment.

Can I recover lost wages if I am undocumented?

Usually yes. In Balbuena v. IDR Realty, New York’s Court of Appeals held that the federal Immigration Reform and Control Act does not bar an undocumented worker from recovering lost wages in a Labor Law case, at least where the worker did not present false work-authorization documents to get the job.

The court also said the jury may consider immigration status when deciding how much in future lost wages to award. That is why these cases need careful preparation: what you earned, how long you have worked in New York and what work you could have done in the future all matter. Medical expenses and pain and suffering are not affected by status.

Part of the claim Affected by immigration status?
Medical bills, past and future No
Pain and suffering No
Past lost wages Generally recoverable (Balbuena)
Future lost earnings Recoverable, but status may be considered in the amount
Workers’ compensation benefits Generally available regardless of status

Will filing a claim get me reported to immigration?

An injury lawsuit is a civil case between you and the companies responsible. What you tell your lawyer is confidential and protected by attorney-client privilege. Courts in many cases limit how much the defense can ask about status, and judges decide those questions case by case. We do not ask about your status to take your case, and we will explain what may come up before anything is filed. If you also have an immigration question, our firm has immigration attorneys you can speak with separately.

What should I do after a construction accident in New York?

  1. Get medical care and say the injury happened at work.
  2. Report the accident to your foreman or employer in writing within 30 days, and keep a copy or a photo of it.
  3. Write down the site address, the general contractor’s name from the permit sign, your employer and the coworkers who saw it.
  4. Do not sign anything you do not understand, in any language, before talking to a lawyer.
  5. Watch the deadlines: generally three years for a lawsuit, but only 90 days for a notice of claim if a city agency owns the site.

Our New York construction accident lawyer page explains the Labor Law, who can be responsible and how we handle these cases, and our New York personal injury lawyer page covers other injuries.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a Social Security number to file an injury claim in New York?

No. You can bring a personal injury claim without a Social Security number. Some paperwork, such as proof of earnings, may be handled differently, and your lawyer can explain how pay stubs, bank records or employer testimony can show what you earned.

Can I get workers’ compensation if I am undocumented in New York?

Generally yes. New York workers’ compensation covers employees injured on the job regardless of immigration status. Report the injury to your employer in writing and file a claim with the Workers’ Compensation Board, generally within two years.

What if I was paid in cash?

Being paid in cash does not mean you cannot recover. Lost wages can often be shown with bank deposits, text messages about pay, coworker testimony or the contractor’s own records. Keep anything that shows the days you worked and what you were paid.

Hurt on a New York job site? Call (332) 266-6524 — free, confidential consultation, open 24 hours.

No fees or costs unless we win. Hablamos español.