The Bottom Line
- Labor Law § 240(1), the “Scaffold Law,” requires owners and contractors to provide proper safety devices for work at height: scaffolds, ladders, hoists, ropes, harnesses and similar equipment.
- If a missing or inadequate device was a cause of your fall, or of an object falling on you, the owner and contractor are responsible, and your own carelessness generally does not reduce the claim.
- The main defense is that the worker’s own conduct was the sole cause of the accident. Homeowners of one- and two-family houses who do not direct the work are exempt.
- Most claims must be filed within three years; public owners need a notice of claim within 90 days. No fees or costs unless we win: (332) 266-6524.
Most states treat a fall at work like any other accident: the injured worker gets workers’ compensation, and a lawsuit against anyone else depends on proving negligence, with the worker’s own mistakes counted against them. New York is different. For more than a century it has put the responsibility for height safety on the people who own the building and run the job, because they control the equipment and the schedule, and the worker on the scaffold does not.
What does Labor Law § 240(1) require?
The law says contractors and owners, and their agents, must furnish or have furnished scaffolding, hoists, stays, ladders, slings, hangers, blocks, pulleys, braces, irons, ropes and other devices that are constructed, placed and operated so as to give proper protection to a person doing covered work at height.
Covered work includes erecting, demolishing, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning or pointing a building or structure. Routine maintenance, such as changing a light bulb, usually is not covered, and the line between repair and maintenance is one of the most argued questions in these cases.
What kinds of accidents does the Scaffold Law cover?
| Usually covered | Usually not covered |
|---|---|
| Fall from a scaffold that collapsed, tipped or had no guardrails | A trip and fall on the same level (may fall under § 241(6) or § 200 instead) |
| Fall from an unsecured or defective ladder | Routine maintenance not connected to construction or repair |
| Fall through an unprotected floor opening, roof edge or shaft | Injury where the worker’s own conduct was the only cause |
| Struck by material or equipment that fell while being hoisted or because it was not secured | Work for an owner of a one- or two-family home who did not direct or control it |
Does my own mistake matter?
Generally no. Under § 240(1), comparative negligence is not a defense: if the owner or contractor violated the statute and the violation was a cause of the injury, your share of the blame does not reduce the recovery. Only if your own conduct was the sole cause of the accident does the claim fail.
Courts have applied the “sole cause” defense, for example, when a worker had adequate safety devices available, knew they were expected to use them, and chose not to for no good reason. That is a fact question, and owners and their insurers raise it often. Evidence about what equipment was actually on site, and what the foreman told the crew, matters.
Who pays under the Scaffold Law?
The owner of the property and the general contractor, and sometimes a construction manager or subcontractor that had authority over the work. They are responsible even if they were not on site and even if a subcontractor’s crew set up the scaffold. Your own employer generally cannot be sued because of the workers’ compensation law, but you can usually receive compensation benefits and bring the Scaffold Law claim against the owner and contractor at the same time.
What should I do after a fall at a New York job site?
- Get medical care and tell the doctor the injury happened at work.
- Report the accident to your foreman or employer in writing and keep a copy.
- Write down the site address, the general contractor’s name from the permit sign or fence, and coworkers who saw the fall.
- If it is safe, photograph the scaffold, ladder or opening before it is changed.
- Talk to a lawyer before signing any statement for an insurer.
Our New York construction accident lawyer page explains the other Labor Law sections, deadlines and how we handle these cases, and our New York personal injury lawyer page covers other injury claims.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the New York Scaffold Law only about scaffolds?
No. Despite the name, it covers falls from ladders, roofs, beams and floor openings, and injuries from objects that fall because they were being hoisted or were not properly secured. The question is whether the work involved an elevation-related risk and whether proper safety devices were provided.
Can the owner blame me for not tying off my harness?
Only in limited cases. Your own carelessness generally does not reduce a § 240(1) claim. The owner must show your conduct was the sole cause, for example that adequate anchor points and harnesses were available, you knew you were expected to use them, and you chose not to without a good reason.
How long do I have to bring a Scaffold Law claim?
Generally three years from the accident. If the owner is New York City or another public agency, a notice of claim is usually due within 90 days and the lawsuit within one year and 90 days, so call a lawyer right away.
Fell at a New York job site? Call (332) 266-6524 — free consultation, open 24 hours.
No fees or costs unless we win. Hablamos español.