Skip to Main Content

Left-Turn Crash on Kendall Drive or US-1: Who Is at Fault in Florida?


By The Attorneys of Jimenez Mazzitelli Mordes

The Bottom Line

  • Florida law (section 316.122) requires a driver turning left to yield to oncoming traffic that is in the intersection or close enough to be a hazard.
  • That makes the left-turning driver the usual starting point for fault, but not the automatic answer: speeding, red-light running or a protected green arrow can shift it.
  • Florida’s modified comparative fault rule reduces your recovery by your share of fault and bars recovery if you are more than 50% at fault.
  • Video from plazas and gas stations often decides these cases, and it can be overwritten within days.

Kendall Drive is one long run of left turns. Drivers cross three lanes of oncoming traffic to reach a plaza, a gas station or a side street, often in heavy traffic and sometimes on a flashing yellow arrow. Along US-1 around Dadeland and through Pinecrest and Palmetto Bay, the same thing happens at the big signalized intersections and the driveways between them. When a left turn goes wrong, the result is usually a T-bone or an offset front-end crash, one of the most injury-heavy crash types there is, because the side of a car has little room to absorb the impact.

Who is usually at fault in a left-turn crash?

Usually the driver turning left. Florida law requires a left-turning driver to yield the right-of-way to any vehicle coming from the opposite direction that is in the intersection or so close that it is an immediate hazard. If the turn was made into that gap, the turning driver is generally at fault.

That rule is the starting point insurers use too, so if you were going straight and got hit by a turning car, the other driver’s insurer may accept fault quickly. If you were the one turning, do not assume you have no claim. The rule depends on the facts.

When the driver going straight shares the blame

Fault can move partly or entirely to the oncoming driver when, for example:

  • The oncoming driver ran a red light or entered on a late yellow while you were finishing a lawful turn.
  • You had a protected green arrow, which gives the turning driver the right-of-way.
  • The oncoming driver was speeding, so a gap that looked safe disappeared.
  • The oncoming car had no headlights on at night, or the driver was distracted or impaired.
  • A third vehicle blocked the view or waved you through (a wave does not shift fault by itself, but the full sequence matters).

Florida uses modified comparative fault. A jury assigns each driver a percentage, and your recovery is reduced by yours. If you are found more than 50% at fault, you recover nothing in most negligence cases. That is why the evidence matters even when the basic rule seems to point one way.

Situation Usual starting point What can change it
Turning on a solid green, no arrow Turning driver must yield Oncoming speeding, red-light running, no headlights
Turning on a green arrow Turning driver has right-of-way Proof the arrow had already changed
Turning on a flashing yellow arrow Turning driver must yield Oncoming driver’s speed or inattention
Turning into a plaza driveway mid-block Turning driver must yield Oncoming driver changing lanes or speeding

What evidence proves who had the right-of-way?

  • Video from businesses, gas stations, traffic cameras and dashcams. Ask for it fast.
  • Signal timing at the intersection, which can show which phase was showing.
  • The crash report and witness statements.
  • Vehicle event data, which can record speed and braking in the seconds before impact.
  • The damage pattern, which shows the angle and the speeds involved.

If you need the report, see how to get a crash report in Miami. Our guide on how liability is determined after a Miami car accident goes into the general rules.

Who pays your medical bills while fault is being decided?

Your own PIP, regardless of fault. Florida PIP pays 80% of reasonable medical bills and 60% of lost income up to $10,000, as long as you get care within 14 days. Claims for pain and suffering and for losses beyond PIP go against the at-fault driver’s bodily injury coverage or your uninsured motorist coverage. Most Florida car accident lawsuits must be filed within two years of the crash.

Talk to a lawyer about a Kendall left-turn crash

Our Kendall and Dadeland car accident lawyer page explains how we handle crashes in this part of the county, and our Miami car accident lawyers handle auto claims across Miami-Dade.

Call (305) 548-8750 — free consultation, open 24 hours.

No fees or costs unless we win. Hablamos español.